So I am happily knitting along on the restarted Raspy, and I notice it's sort of wide. I get out the measuring tape and check the width. It's 21.5 inches (55cm)- exactly what it's supposed to be. The gauge is even spot on. I keep going thinking, "this still looks really wide to me." So, I get out a favorite pull-over of mine and place Raspy on top.

click to make the "oh crap" moment bigger
As you can see, it's wider than the pull-over. AHHHH!! This doesn't make any sense. I am knitting the largest size- XL which fits a size 40" (102cm) chest. I am actually a 38" (97cm) chest, which is what the pulli is above. The measurements that Rowan gives are a bit suspect...
For example, the pattern states the back/front should be 21.5" (55 cm) wide. But, if I double that, I get 43" (110cm). So, does that mean that Raspy's fit is big? If I really want a tighter fit, should I frog and start another size? If I use the measurements from the pull-over then according to Rowan's measurements I should knit a size SMALL which they also say is for a size 34" (86cm) chest. ARGH! I really want this sweater to be right, so what do you all think I should do?
P.S. Thanks for all the suggestions for my last Raspy dilemma. I think I am going to save the already-knitted-yarn for the sleeves so if there is a visible difference, it will be on the sleeves and not halfway up the front.







